Interesting positions that came up in Copenhagen

[MostFamousDane]

Shot of the tournament

Black to move and win
(taken from game between Sean Phillips vs Graham Young)

Game of the tournament

[pdn][Event "Danish Open 2012"]
[Black "Sune Thrane"]
[White "Bill Dobbins"]
[Round "4"]
[Date "2012.04.21"]
[Site "Copenhagen"]
[GameType "21"]
[Result "0-1"]

9-14 22-18 5-9 25-22 12-16 24-20 8-12 27-24 10-15 24-19 15-24 28-19 7-10 31-27 10-15
19-10 6-15 27-24 2-6 32-28 6-10 24-19 15-24 28-19 1-6 22-17 9-13 18-2 13-31 30-25
10-14 25-22 3-8 2-6 31-27 6-9 27-25 29-22 16-23 9-27 11-16 20-11 8-15 27-24 4-8
21-17 8-11 17-14 11-16 24-20 16-19 20-16 19-23 16-11 15-19 11-15 23-26 15-24 0-1[/pdn]

Quote of the tournament:

(In reference to the fact that the little mermaid has had its head stolen twice): "Well she has only lost her head twice since 1913 that's a lot less than most women"

[MostFamousDane]

12-16 is a weak line; white should have capitalized with 32-27 instead of 31-27. But after 31-27 10-15 x 27-24, then 2-7 wins easily for red.

I disagree - I know 32-27 is PP but it is an unusual and illogical looking move. Moves like 22-17 or 29-25 (or the 31-27 taken) look natural but all loses.

[MostFamousDane]

If the other moves all lose, then what exactly are you disagreeing with?

Ok let me make my point very clear

9-14
22-18
5-9
25-22 (the weak move, 24-20 is better)
12-16 (very strong move)
24-20
8-12
27-24 (here both 28-24 and 29-25 losses)
10-15
24-19 (29-25 still loses)
15-24
7-10

From here innocent looking moves like 22-17 and 29-25 loses and indeed a losing move was made.

When you said 12-16 is a weak line so I assumed you meant 12-16 was the weak move ???

[Alex_Moiseyev]

Sune, you didn't say anything about first red move 9-14. Is it weak or not ?

Alex

[MostFamousDane]

Sune, you didn't say anything about first red move 9-14. Is it weak or not ?

Alex

Eh ??????????????

The tournament was three move - but assuming it wasn't then 9-14 is weak since 11-15 is better. Do you disagree with my assement ?

[Alex_Moiseyev]

then 9-14 is weak since 11-15 is better. Do you disagree with my assement ?

Maybe not, it depends on very important fact - who is my opponent

I did play 12-16 several times on serious occasion, but usually I am using a pitch line:

9-14, 22-18, 5-9, 25-22, 12-16, 24-20, 10-15 (A), 27-24, 15-19, 24x15, 16-19, 23x16, 14x23, 26x19, 11x25, 29x22, 8-12 etc

A. 8-12 looks wreckless to me and goes against my personality

Alex

[MostFamousDane]

then 9-14 is weak since 11-15 is better. Do you disagree with my assement ?

Maybe not, it depends on very important fact - who is my opponent

I did play 12-16 several times on serious occasion, but usually I am using a pitch line:

9-14, 22-18, 5-9, 25-22, 12-16, 24-20, 10-15 (A), 27-24, 15-19, 24x15, 16-19, 23x16, 14x23, 26x19, 11x25, 29x22, 8-12 etc

A. 8-12 looks wreckless to me and goes against my personality

Alex

You are right 8-12 is wreckless for the opponent and forces him to make a series of star moves to obtain the draw

When that is said I also like your line.

[Alex_Moiseyev]

You are right 8-12 is wreckless for the opponent and forces him to make a series of star moves to obtain the draw

You are tough !!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8K54DPF6asw

[MostFamousDane]

You are right 8-12 is wreckless for the opponent and forces him to make a series of star moves to obtain the draw

You are tough !!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8K54DPF6asw

LOL - great video - it illustrates the kind of play white has to pull to draw